Chapter 7 - The Subpoena and the Silence
The legal machinery of the state of Ohio moved with the ponderous, grinding inevitability of a glacier.
Within two weeks of the incident, the Franklin County Prosecutor’s office officially filed criminal charges against sixty-four-year-old Diane Miller: one count of domestic assault, a first-degree misdemeanor, and one count of child endangerment, a third-degree felony.
Richard tried to call me three times during that fortnight. I didn't answer his calls, but I forwarded every voicemail straight to my divorce attorney, Sarah Jenkins, who used them as Exhibit A in our emergency petition for sole custody and exclusive use of the residential property.
On a crisp Tuesday afternoon in early December, Sarah and I sat in her downtown office overlooking the state capitol building, reviewing the preliminary financial disclosures.
“His startup accounts are completely locked up,” Sarah said, sliding a thick binder across her mahogany desk. “Between the legal defense fund for his mother and the cash withdrawals he funneled to her over the last year, Richard’s personal liquidity is zero. He’s currently crashing on a pull-out couch in his brother Greg’s basement in Dublin.”
“And the house?” I asked, leaning back in the leather client chair.
“The residential deed is in your maiden name and your married name jointly, but under the temporary restraining orders and the domestic violence filings, Judge Henderson has granted you exclusive possession of the property for the duration of the divorce proceedings,” Sarah explained, tapping her pen against the paper. “He can’t set foot within five hundred feet of the front steps, and neither can Diane.”
I felt a profound sense of weight lifting off my shoulders—the invisible, crushing anchor I had carried for seven years of walking on eggshells in my own home.
“What about the criminal trial?” I asked.
“Diane’s defense attorney tried to file a motion to dismiss, claiming maternal privilege and reasonable corporal correction,” Sarah smiled grimly. “Judge Henderson laughed it out of chambers. The trial date is set for the second week of January. Prosecutor Walsh has subpoenaed the medical records from the pediatrician, the police report from Officer Miller, and—most damagingly—the security camera footage from your neighbor across the street.”
“My neighbor’s camera caught it?” I asked, surprised.
“The Ring doorbell on the house directly across your cul-de-sac captured the audio of Diane screaming ‘Greedy children eat last’ right through your open dining room window,” Sarah said. “It’s crystal clear. There’s no spinning that for a jury.”
When I left Sarah’s office and drove home to pick up Lily from her neighborhood elementary school, the sky was a pale, clear winter blue.
As I pulled into our driveway, I noticed a familiar gray sedan parked three houses down the street.
Inside sat Richard.
He hadn't gotten out of the car. He sat behind the steering wheel, his hands resting limply at the ten-and-two position, staring up at our house with a hollow, haunted expression. He looked smaller than he had at the dinner table—his hair uncombed, his suit jacket wrinkled across the backseat.
I didn't honk. I didn't yell. I simply pulled my SUV into our garage, clicked the automatic door closed, and walked inside.
Ten minutes later, the doorbell rang.
I didn't open it immediately. I checked the peephole. It was Richard, standing alone on the porch, his hands jammed deep into his coat pockets against the freezing wind.
I unlocked the deadbolt, opened the door six inches, and kept the security chain firmly engaged.
“What do you want, Richard?” I asked, my voice flat.
He looked through the gap, his eyes red-rimmed and pleading. “Elena... please. Just five minutes. Can I... can I see Lily?”
“No,” I said simply.
“Elena, she’s my daughter!” he choked out, his voice cracking. “Mom is facing prison time. My firm dropped me. I’m living in a basement, and my life is completely destroyed. Can’t you show a little mercy?”
“Mercy?” I stared at him through the crack in the door. “Where was your mercy when your mother hit our seven-year-old child across the face and told her she didn't deserve to eat? Where was your mercy when you stood by and watched her terrorize this house for two years?”
Richard swallowed hard, a tear freezing on his eyelashes. “I was weak, Elena. I was afraid of her.”
May you like
“Yes, you were,” I agreed. “And your weakness nearly destroyed my daughter. You can see Lily when the family court judge allows it, under supervised visitation, once your mother’s criminal trial is resolved. Until then, don't come back to this house.”
Before he could speak another word, I clicked the security chain home and pushed the heavy oak door shut, leaving him standing out in the cold where he belonged.
