Chapter 3 - Bloodline Betrayal
Detective Miller read the messages on my phone screen in complete silence.
He was a thickset man in his late forties, with cropped salt-and-pepper hair, tired wrinkles around his eyes, and the world-weary posture of someone who had spent decades staring into the darkest corners of human cruelty. Beside him stood his partner, a younger female officer whose name tag read *Cruz*, and Elena Vance—no relation to me, though the shared surname brought a bitter twist to my mouth—an emergency caseworker from the Department of Child and Family Services.
As Miller scrolled through the text chain, his eyebrows steadily climbed toward his hairline.
"You hit your sister?" Miller asked, looking up from the phone, his gaze locking onto my split knuckles.
"Yes," I said without a single second of hesitation. "I slapped her open-handed across the face immediately after she laughed and told me Rosie’s burns were a joke to 'toughen her up.' If you want to arrest me for battery, you go ahead and slap the handcuffs on me right now. But only after my daughter is treated, and only after you send a squad car to put Bethany in an interrogation room."
Detective Cruz moved closer to the exam table, leaning down to view Rosie’s arms as Dr. Lin began applying silver sulfadiazine burn cream. Cruz’s face paled beneath her tan, her nostrils flaring in visible disgust.
"Detective," Dr. Lin said, her tone razor-sharp. "I am the attending physician, and as a mandatory reporter under state law, I am officially submitting a report of aggravated child abuse with a deadly or heated instrument. These burns are intentional, patterned, and consistent with torture. The facial contusions indicate blunt-force trauma to a four-year-old. Whoever did this belongs in a holding cell, not in a civil custody dispute."
Elena, the social worker, was already scribbling furiously on a legal pad. "Mr. Vance, who has legal custody of Rosie?"
"I do," I answered immediately. "Sole legal and physical custody. My wife passed away during childbirth. My parents have never had legal guardianship, though they’ve provided occasional childcare—which stops tonight. Forever."
"Has your sister ever displayed violent behavior toward Rosie before?" Elena asked, her eyes sharp and assessing.
I opened my mouth to say *no*, but the word caught in my throat.
Memory, cruel and illuminating, flashed through my mind like a reel of corrupted film.
Six months ago, Rosie had come home from an afternoon at my parents’ house with a mysterious bruise on the back of her thigh. Bethany had claimed Rosie fell down the wooden stairs while chasing the family golden retriever.
Three months ago, Rosie woke up screaming from nightmares, begging me not to leave her alone in rooms with "the clicker lady." I had dismissed it as the vivid, nonsensical imagination of a toddler coping with preschool transitions.
*God forgive me,* I thought, bile scalding my esophagus. *It wasn't an accident. It was never an accident.*
"She has," I whispered, the realization hitting me like a freight train. "Bethany has always had... episodes. When we were teenagers, she drowned my brother’s pet rabbit in the swimming pool because he wouldn't let her use his car. My parents covered it up. They told the neighbors the rabbit escaped into the woods. When she was expelled from boarding school for cutting a classmate's hair off while she slept, my father made a fifty-thousand-dollar donation to the building fund and had her records expunged."
Detective Miller pulled a digital voice recorder from his tactical vest, set it on the bedside tray, and hit record.
"State your full name and date of birth for the record, Mr. Vance."
"Julian Vance. September 14, 1994."
"And the suspect?"
"Bethany Vance. August 22, 1998. Residing at 442 Crestview Terrace—my parents' estate."
Before Miller could ask his next question, my phone began vibrating violently on the metal tray again.
The screen flashed: **DANIEL (BROTHER).**
Daniel was twenty-one, the youngest of us, a college junior who had been sitting on the couch during the party, his face glued to his phone. He had never had the stomach to confront our father, but he wasn't cruel like Bethany.
I grabbed the phone and hit speaker. "Daniel?"
"Julian?" Daniel’s voice was frantic, breathless, coming through in a panicked whisper over the roar of background shouting. "Julian, where are you? Don't go to your apartment!"
My spine went rigid. "Daniel, what are you talking about?"
"Dad called Uncle Howard!" Daniel choked out, speaking so fast his words tripped over each other. Uncle Howard was my father’s former college roommate, a senior partner at one of the most ruthless corporate litigation firms in the state. "They’re claiming you took Rosie while having a violent psychotic breakdown. Bethany went to an urgent care clinic in town to document her broken cheekbone, and Dad sent two private security guys from his company to your apartment complex. They’re waiting for you there, Julian. They took Rosie’s spare clothes, her medical records from your desk, and your backup hard drives!"
Detective Miller immediately leaned over the phone. "Son, who is this?"
Daniel went dead silent for a second, terrified. "Who... who is that?"
"This is Detective Miller, Metro PD," the detective barked, his voice commanding and sharp. "Are you currently at the Crestview Terrace residence?"
"I... yes, sir," Daniel stammered.
"Did you witness your sister Bethany Vance in the bathroom with Rosie Vance tonight?"
There was a long, agonizing pause. I could hear the faint sound of my mother screaming in the background of the call, cursing my name, blaming me for ruining her life.
"Daniel," I pleaded, tears threatening to spill over again. "Look at what they’re doing. Look at Rosie. She’s four years old. She has third-degree burns all over her arms. Did you know? Did you see Bethany take her into that bathroom?"
A choked sob came through the line.
"I saw Bethany grab her by the wrist after Rosie knocked over the punch cup," Daniel whispered, his voice trembling so hard the microphone crackled. "Rosie was crying, and Bethany dragged her down the hall toward the guest bath. She was holding Dad's vintage car lighter from his study. The one shaped like an eagle head. I thought she was just going to scare her with it... I didn't think... God, Julian, I didn't think she’d actually do it!"
Miller’s pen flew across his notepad. He looked at Officer Cruz and pointed toward the door. "Get a warrant request to Judge Alvarez right now. Felony aggravated child abuse, witness tampering, and obstruction. Put a patrol car outside Julian’s apartment, and dispatch a unit to pick up Bethany Vance wherever she’s getting that cheek examined."
Cruz bolted out of the room, radio already glued to her lips.
"Daniel," I said into the phone. "Where is the lighter now?"
"Dad took it," Daniel whispered, terrified. "He threw it into the fireplace in the study. He’s trying to melt the residue off the metal right now."
May you like
Miller swore under his breath, clicked his radio, and shouted, "Cruz! Add evidence destruction to that warrant! Send the units to Crestview Terrace with sirens hot!"
---
